A few weeks ago, I accepted a challenge from a coworker to
try a dietary experiment: live off of supplements for an entire workweek.
The Deal:
Only nutritional supplements were to be consumed from Monday
through Friday for one week.
Nutritional supplements could include beverages (such as
Boost, Ensure, or Carnation Breakfast) or solids (such as protein bars) but
could not incorporate non-supplement foods.
Overall diet must be adequate in calories and nutrients,
with a goal of weight maintenance.
Sunday afternoon, I went grocery shopping… it was so sad. I
purchased real food for my husband to eat and Ensure, Boost, and Glucerna bars
for myself to eat for the week. I had calculated my estimated needs based on
weight and activity level that I would need a baseline of 1500-1700 Calories
and 46-60g of protein (more calories if I was more active). This worked out to
6-7 nutritional supplements per day (for example, 6 bottles of Ensure/Boost; or
5 bottles of Ensure plus 1 bottle of Boost fruit juice plus one Glucerna bar).
On Sunday evening, I made my “last supper” of Cajun salmon, basmati rice, and
broccoli with a few pieces of mint chocolate for dessert. I savored every last
bite.
The Experience:
Packing my lunch on Monday morning before work was easy. I
tossed a vanilla Ensure and a chocolate Boost into my lunch bag, then added a
Glucerna lemon crisp bar in for an afternoon snack. I downed a Carnation
Instant Breakfast as I headed out the door, shuddered a little at the chalky
flavour and realized I was in for a very long week.
I was pretty hungry by the time lunch rolled around, but
eating at the lunchroom table with my coworkers and their real food was
probably the easiest on Monday; it got tougher with each passing day of no real
food. One thing I was surprised to find was that I actually did experience
satiety after meals when I had 2 liquid supplements to drink (400-500 Calories).
I always had two different flavours per meal to try and avoid taste fatigue. I
always needed an afternoon snack by 3pm, but was fine for the evening after
supper. There were definitely better flavours than others; if I never taste
another vanilla or strawberry Ensure again I won’t be losing any sleep over it.
On the other hand, the high protein chocolate Ensure was actually really nice
and creamy and the fruit flavoured Boost beverages were okay served chilled over
ice.
Supper was the toughest meal of the day from the start.
Breakfast was easy, and lunch was tolerable, but every evening following a day
of super-sweet supplements all I wanted was to eat some savory foods and have
something to chew that wasn’t in bar form.
Monday and Tuesday weren’t so bad, really. I actually was
feeling pretty good to be honest. I still had lots of energy, and had
absolutely no desire to over eat.
Wednesday was when I started to crack. It wasn’t so much the energy levels,
because I was getting sufficient calories and nutrients and spreading them out
throughout the day with calculated precision. But mentally, I was really
missing food. And my gut started really hating me (probably due to the
ridiculous amount of sugar I was taking in combined with a lack of bulk). I
took fiber supplements but this really didn’t do much to improve the situation.
By Thursday at lunch, I even had a toothache. That was it. Psychologically, I
was finished, and so admitted defeat Thursday evening. As soon as I got home, I sliced up and
ate a tomato with nothing else. It was the best little tomato I’ve ever had.
After making sure that my stomach would tolerate real food again, I ate some
crackers and cheese. Supper was chicken, veggies, and rice. It seems simple,
but damn real food is delicious.
The Lesson:
Okay, so I didn’t make it through Friday as planned. But I
did make it through 3.75 days. My weight stayed totally stable and my energy
levels were good. I guess in that sense, a calorie is a calorie when we’re
looking at weight and surprisingly also in terms of energy (at least in the
short term). But I was totally fiber deficient and can now really truly empathize
with my inpatients that are sick and tired of drinking supplements to gain
weight. If nothing else, this experiment tells me that yes it is possible to
feel full and maintain weight on supplements alone (or if manipulated
appropriately, gain or lose weight). But it gives me a new appreciation for
many of my patients who complain that drinking these things is way too sweet,
and I’ll definitely be adjusting my practice habits to better reflect their preferences
from this point forward. It also reaffirms my belief that just because I am
young and healthy now doesn’t mean that I shouldn’t renew my decision every day
to eat well and stay fit. Doing these things now will help me to prevent
chronic disease down the road… so if that means that I’m less likely to be
bedridden with illness in the hospital and drinking supplements to improve my
nutritional status when I’m older then it is worth every healthy choice that I
make at this stage of life!






